Tenant Logo

Accident Audit

After an accident, the damage recorded once, with nothing missed

After a collision, the damage is surveyed under pressure, and the repair scope and cost are argued from photographs on phones.

What SmartFleet does

  • Places each item of damage on the car drawing, with photographs
  • Records the scope and the cost of each repair
  • Follows each item through repair and close-out
  • Charts the damage by category and cost

Optional expert review: crashworthiness assessment

Give us the crash data and the damage survey. Our reviewing engineer reconstructs the impact, assesses each structural zone on its own plate of the same record, and marks the items the review clears. What the survey had down for replacement but the load path shows is within limits comes off the claim, with the verdict and the report signed beside the damage.

What the review delivers

  • An impact reconstruction from the crash data: the energy that went into each structural zone
  • A verdict per zone, signed beside the damage item: stayed elastic, yielded locally, or replace
  • The items the verdict clears marked on the claim, so the repair scope and the cost come down
  • An independent engineering report on the accident record, and a clear answer on whether a full finite element analysis is needed at all

Why the review avoids unnecessary strip-down

After a collision the survey sees the outside. A bent buffer beam may or may not have passed its load into the headstock, the solebars and the body behind it. Without evidence the safe answer is to strip: buffers off, coupler out, the headstock opened up and inspected, often replaced. Weeks of downtime, much of it to find nothing.

The review works the other way round. From the speed, the masses and the geometry it reconstructs the energy of the impact and follows it through the structure, zone by zone. Where the force stayed below the yield point of a zone, that zone sprang back: there is nothing to find there, and nothing to strip. The stripping stops at the last zone that yielded.

Each zone gets one of three verdicts, signed beside the damage item:

  • Elastic, no structural repair: inspect in place and release
  • Yielded locally: repair that part, nothing behind it
  • Replace: beyond repair
Before the review
Strip down to be sure
Buffers off, coupler out, the headstock opened and inspected, parts replaced because nobody can prove they held. The vehicle is out of service for weeks, and much of the work finds nothing.
After the review
Strip only what yielded
The energy of the impact is quantified and followed through the structure. Zones that stayed within their elastic limit are inspected in place and released. The strip-down is confined to the zones that yielded, with the evidence signed on the record.

In our demonstration a locomotive struck a trailer at a level crossing at about 25 mph. The buffer beam bent 14 mm and yielded locally, so it is straightened and re-welded, not replaced. The headstock behind it stayed below yield everywhere, so the two buffers the survey had down for replacement are cleared and their heads straightened. The cab structure stayed elastic. Only the cracked windscreen is replaced. Five zones assessed, one replacement, no strip-down of the headstock.

From our demonstration

Chart: the repair claim added up by part of the locomotive
The claim by part of the vehicle: the cab end carries most of it.
Chart: the five structural zones by the verdict of the review
The review verdicts: two zones yielded locally and are repaired, two stayed elastic, one is replaced.

Experienced engineers do this work with AI assistants, and a person signs every verdict. How it is done.

Your specification, running live.

Send us one of your maintenance specifications, procedures or checklists, or the engineering problem you want solved, and we'll show it to you working in SmartFleet: your tasks, your limits, your signatures.

Send us your specification